Monday, April 19, 2004

Hitching our wagons to Hollywood: At Ninth Art, Bulent Yusuf wonders what long-term effect "celebrity writers" like Kevin Smith, Bryan Singer and Joss Whedon will have on the comics industry:

"In the short term, there is positive publicity, yes, and both the die-hard fans and the casual reader may well snap up the first couple of issues. There's a crossover appeal, where the TV/film audience for the work of the celebrity wordsmith might be tempted to check out their work in comics. Sales go up, and the industry lives to fight another day.

"In the long term, however, we should be asking how qualified these celebrities are to determine the futures of our favourite characters. It sounds pompous, but writing funny books is a serious business, and they have a sophisticated audience. If one of these celebrities underestimates the workings of the medium, then their book will be an embarrassing failure, and the market gets cheapened that little bit more (if that's possible)."